How to save a health system from drowning

Filed in: Article.

By Professor Ian Brighthope
As it appears in Food matters

Here is my version of a very worn modern parable.

A surgeon runs by a fast flowing river when he hears the cry of a man drowning. The surgeon submerges, puts his arms around the victim, takes him to the ground and resuscitates him. He resumes his trot, only to see another man drowning. Drag the second man and make him breathe. The surgeon jogs again, but in a short time he meets another man who is drowning and another.

In search of help, call a practitioner of complementary medicine, who is nearby, absorbed in his thoughts. The surgeon calls him to go after a suffocating victim while attending to the other. When the complementary medicine practitioner is slow to respond, the surgeon shouts, "Why are not you doing anything?"

The complementary practitioner finally responds: "I'm doing something. I'm trying desperately to find out who is pulling all these people into the river. "

This story illustrates one of the ongoing dilemmas in our current health system, a system so desperately occupied in the treatment of pathological endpoints of the disease, that more and more people are seeking medical attention, waiting in beds. the hospitals, queue for surgical interventions, have little hope of contemplating what brought these people there in the first place.

This does not mean that such efforts are necessarily useless, or that a considerable amount of good is not being achieved in the short term. However, the system is so preoccupied with what sociologist John McKinlay has called "top-down efforts": "shallow categorical tweaks in response to almost perennial changes from one health problem to another," which has little chance of actually solving anything. [1]

The current system is so busy fishing people out of the river, that they have little time to contemplate the causes, implement prevention or "medicine upstream".

I am speaking in extreme terms here, of course, there are many conventional doctors who implement prevention, lifestyle reforms, etc., but mainly they are the complementary health professionals who are achieving these ends, even though they are not receiving recognition. they deserve, especially from surgeons.

Things are certainly changing, however, the situation remains, in the best of cases, a progression of "two steps forward, one step backwards". Against the armamentarium of the big pharmaceutical companies, nutritional supplements are often seen as a novel element, something to be played but that should not be taken so seriously. Patients deserve "something that really works", as opposed to a false mix of vitamins and minerals, things that we should get from our diet anyway. However, conservative doctors are taking note.

However, as Dr. Andrew Weil, an enthusiastic advocate of nutritional supplements, has suggested, this is a medical system that is on the verge of collapse anyway. He trusts, like many of us, that when the collapse finally occurs, a new integrating medical model will emerge. An "ascending" model, which encourages people to "express ownership of their own health" rather than leaving it to others, waiting for it to be saved by medications and surgeons and the hospital system, and to be resurrected when they submit

Read Also  What is your body trying to tell you? 9 symptoms that you should not ignore

1. B. McKinlay, J., A case to refocus upwards: the political economy of the disease. 3rd ed. ed. Patients, doctors and diseases: a reference book on behavioral science and health.
ed. E.G. Jaco 1979, New York: Free Press; London: Collier-Macmillan. xiv, 479 p.


Comments are closed here.

You May Also Like:
Not all whey protein is created the same
When you hear the words WHEY PROTEIN, you can often think of muscle building powders in many bodybuilding stores. The truth is that many

Why the diet mentality can keep you from losing weight
A child's school project quickly becomes a lesson that we can all benefit from! Watch this short video to reinforce one of the reasons

12 essential oils for Mother's Day
Essential oils are taking over! And it's a great thing! You have probably listened to your friends, family or even seen on social networks,

Are feminine hygiene products slowing you down? (More safe alternatives)
Gluten-free is stuck everywhere these days … Ask anybody and they probably bought a gluten-free product or tried to eliminate gluten. Ask these same

Why I love FMTV (Food MattersTV)
Researchers at the Mayo Clinic were analyzing the blood of people with suspected Lyme, and discovered unexpected findings in six of the 9,000 patients

7 tips for fun in the sun!
Packaging for your next vacation or day in the sun? EWG thinks that these items should never enter your suitcase, beach bag or backpack.

Vitamin C can kill colorectal cancer cells!
While we have known about the beneficial effects of therapy with high doses of nutrients thanks to Dr. Andrew Saul For years, it's exciting

5 DIY recipes to clean the house made with essential oils
The most common cleaning products that you find in your grocery store are loaded with toxic chemicals and contaminants and ingredients designed to make

Appointment on March 5
Source: Comments are closed here.

What do laboratory rats do to induce cancer?
It is difficult to understand the claims of the medical establishment that the cause of cancer and other diseases is unknown, when these diseases

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *